Stated Cases

Please note that the headnotes which appear at the beginning of the Stated Cases on this website have been prepared by BC Assessment staff. They are provided solely for convenience and are not part of the official version.

BCSC: British Columbia Supreme Court
BCCA: British Columbia Court of Appeal
SCC: Supreme Court of Canada
FCC: Federal Court of Canada
FCA: Federal Court of Appeal

New-Stated-Test

Stated Case Number	Neutral Citation	Case Number	Case Name	Reasons for Judgment
001	N/A	https://testinfo.bcassessment.ca/about/Pages/Stated-Cases-Index.aspx	Reginald R. Orr v. City of Vancouver	June 03, 1955
002	N/A	https://testinfo.bcassessment.ca/about/Pages/Stated-Cases-Index.aspx	Montague G. Caple v. City of Vancouver	June 08, 1955
003	N/A	https://testinfo.bcassessment.ca/about/Pages/Stated-Cases-Index.aspx	Burrard Dry Dock Company Limited v. Corporation of the City of North Vancouver	October 31, 1955
004	N/A		Corporation of the District of West Vancouver v. Assessment Commissioner	January 27, 1956
005	N/A		Canadian National Railways Company v. City of Prince Rupert	June 13, 1956
006	N/A		Franck Patterson et al v. The Corporation of the City of North Vancouver	July 19, 1956
007	N/A		Northland Navigation Company v. City of Prince Rupert	June 13, 1956
008	N/A		Canadian Pacific Railway Company v. The Corporation of the City of Port Coquitlam	June 28, 1957
009	N/A		British Columbia Forest Products Limited v. Corporation of the District of Maple Ridge	August 28, 1957
010	N/A		Royalite Oil Company Limited v. Kamloops Assessment District	September 10, 1957
011	N/A		Evans, Coleman & Evans Limited v. The Corporation of the City of Port Coquitlam et al v. The Corporation of the District of Coquitlam	November 15, 1957
012	N/A		Northland Navigation Company Limited v. City of Prince Rupert	May 26, 1958
013	N/A		Theodore G. Pearce and Muriel Ernestine Pearce v. Corporation of the City of New Westminster	July 28, 1958
014	N/A		City of Vancouver v. The Corporation of the Township of Richmond	July 24, 1958 (BCSC)
014-2	N/A		City of Vancouver v. The Corporation of the Township of Richmond	October 31, 1958 (BCCA)
015	N/A		Crown Zellerbach Canada Limited et al v. Assessment District of Alberni et al	August 07, 1958
016	N/A		Assessment Commissioner et al v. British Columbia Electric Company Limited	July 30, 1958
017	N/A		Canadian National Railway Company v. Assessment Commissioner	July 06, 1959
018	N/A		Desautels, Rosaire Horace v. The Corporation of the District of Coquitlam	September 25, 1959
019	N/A		Home Coal Company Limited v. The Corporation of Delta	June 24, 1960
020	N/A		Assessment Commissioner v. H.D.L. Mercer	July 03, 1961
021	N/A		Corporation of the District of Maple Ridge v. British Columbia Forest Products Limited	July 10, 1961
022	N/A		William T. Joyce Company v. Vernon Assessment District	October 10, 1961
023	N/A		Canadian Pacific Railway Company v. The Corporation of the District of Burnaby	September 27, 1961
024	N/A		Shell Oil Company of Canada Limited et al v. The Corporation of the District of North Vancouver	October 5, 1961 (BCSC)
024-2	N/A		Shell Oil Company of Canada Limited et al v. The Corporation of the District of North Vancouver	March 3, 1962 (BCCA)
025	N/A		City of Port Moody v. Canadian Collieries Resources Ltd.	September 19, 1961
026	N/A		Canadian Collieries Resources Limited v. Assessment Districts of Comox and New Westminster	October 03, 1961
027	N/A		MacMillan Bloedel and Powell River Limited et al v. Assessment District of Alberni et al	October 18, 1961
028	N/A		British Columbia Forest Products Limited v. Assessment Districts of Cowichan and Victoria	January 22, 1962 (BCSC)

1 - 30

StatedCasesTest

Stated Case Number	Neutral Citation	Case Name	Reasons for Judgment
001	N/A	Reginald R. Orr v. City of Vancouver	June 03, 1955
002	N/A	Montague G. Caple v. City of Vancouver	June 08, 1955
003	N/A	Burrard Dry Dock Company Limited v. Corporation of the City of North Vancouver	October 31, 1955
004	N/A	Corporation of the District of West Vancouver v. Assessment Commissioner	January 27, 1956
005	N/A	Canadian National Railways Company v. City of Prince Rupert	June 13, 1956
006	N/A	Franck Patterson et al v. The Corporation of the City of North Vancouver	July 19, 1956
007	N/A	Northland Navigation Company v. City of Prince Rupert	June 13, 1956
008	N/A	Canadian Pacific Railway Company v. The Corporation of the City of Port Coquitlam	June 28, 1957
009	N/A	British Columbia Forest Products Limited v. Corporation of the District of Maple Ridge	August 28, 1957
010	N/A	Royalite Oil Company Limited v. Kamloops Assessment District	September 10, 1957
011	N/A	Evans, Coleman & Evans Limited v. The Corporation of the City of Port Coquitlam et al v. The Corporation of the District of Coquitlam	November 15, 1957
012	N/A	Northland Navigation Company Limited v. City of Prince Rupert	May 26, 1958
013	N/A	Theodore G. Pearce and Muriel Ernestine Pearce v. Corporation of the City of New Westminster	July 28, 1958
014	N/A	City of Vancouver v. The Corporation of the Township of Richmond	July 24, 1958 (BCSC)
014-2	N/A	City of Vancouver v. The Corporation of the Township of Richmond	October 31, 1958 (BCCA)
015	N/A	Crown Zellerbach Canada Limited et al v. Assessment District of Alberni et al	August 07, 1958
016	N/A	Assessment Commissioner et al v. British Columbia Electric Company Limited	July 30, 1958
017	N/A	Canadian National Railway Company v. Assessment Commissioner	July 06, 1959
018	N/A	Desautels, Rosaire Horace v. The Corporation of the District of Coquitlam	September 25, 1959
019	N/A	Home Coal Company Limited v. The Corporation of Delta	June 24, 1960
020	N/A	Assessment Commissioner v. H.D.L. Mercer	July 03, 1961
021	N/A	Corporation of the District of Maple Ridge v. British Columbia Forest Products Limited	July 10, 1961
022	N/A	William T. Joyce Company v. Vernon Assessment District	October 10, 1961
023	N/A	Canadian Pacific Railway Company v. The Corporation of the District of Burnaby	September 27, 1961
024	N/A	Shell Oil Company of Canada Limited et al v. The Corporation of the District of North Vancouver	October 5, 1961 (BCSC)
024-2	N/A	Shell Oil Company of Canada Limited et al v. The Corporation of the District of North Vancouver	March 3, 1962 (BCCA)
025	N/A	City of Port Moody v. Canadian Collieries Resources Ltd.	September 19, 1961
026	N/A	Canadian Collieries Resources Limited v. Assessment Districts of Comox and New Westminster	October 03, 1961
027	N/A	MacMillan Bloedel and Powell River Limited et al v. Assessment District of Alberni et al	October 18, 1961
028	N/A	British Columbia Forest Products Limited v. Assessment Districts of Cowichan and Victoria	January 22, 1962 (BCSC)

1 - 30

Name	Case Name	Reasons for Judgment
SC554	Assessor of Area 01 - Capital et al v. Nav Canada and Property Assessment Appeal Board	November 5, 2014
SC553	Paul, John et al v. Assessor of Area 15 - Fraser Valley and Property Assessment Appeal Board	June 27, 2014
SC552	Musqueam Indian Band Board of Review v Musqueam Indian Band	July 31, 2013 (BCSC), April 17, 2015 (BCCA)
SC551	Assessor of Area 09 - Vancouver Sea to Sky Region v. Alsco Canada Corporation and Property Assessment Appeal Board	June 12, 2013
SC550	KBK No. 197 Ventures Ltd v. Asessor of Area 09 - Vancouver Sea to Sky and Property Assessment Appeal Board	June 4, 2013
SC549	Virani, Shiraz v. Assessor of Area 11 - Richmond/Delta and Property Assessment Appeal Board	February 13, 2013
SC548	Assessor of Area 15 - Fraser Valley v. Conair Group Inc. and Property Assessment Appeal Board	January 28, 2013
SC547	Assessor of Area 11 - Richmond/Delta v. CCS Corporation and Property Assessment Appeal Board	December 11, 2012
SC546	Allard, James T v. Assessor of Area 24 - Cariboo and Property Assessment Appeal Board	August 30, 2012
SC545	Pappas, Jacqueline and Theodore v. Assessor of Area 23 - Kamloops and Property Assessment Appeal Board	July 6, 2012
SC544	Beach Town House Apartments Ltd v. Assessor of Area 09 - Vancouver Sea To Sky Region and Property Assessment Appeal Board	July 16, 2012 (BCSC), July 9, 2013 (BCCA)
SC543	Golden Win Investments Ltd v. Assessor of Area 15 - Fraser Valley and Property Assessment Appeal Board	December 6, 2010
SC542	Owners of Strata Plan 226 v. City of White Rock, Assessor of Area 14 - Surrey/White Rock and Property Assessment Appeal Board	September 27, 2010
SC541	Musqueam Indian Band, Block F Land Ltd and Block K Land Ltd v. Assessor of Area 09 - Vancouver Sea to Sky Region and Property Assessment Appeal Board	September 7, 2010 (BCSC), May 1, 2012 (BCCA)
SC540	Helen Falkenberg v. Assessor of Area 26 - Prince George and Property Assessment Appeal Board	August 23, 2010
SC539	571016 B.C. Ltd. and Turbo Properties Ltd. v. Assessor of Area 09 – Vancouver Sea to Sky Region and Property Assessment Appeal Board	June 7, 2010
SC538	The Dance Foundation v. Assessor of Area 09 – Vancouver	May 14, 2010
SC537	Dave Weinrauch and Sons Trucking Ltd. v. Assessor of Area 21 – Nelson/Trail et al	March 23, 2010
SC536	533985 BC Ltd. v. Assessor of Area 01 -- Capital and Property Assessment Appeal Board	March 02, 2010
SC535	Madison Development Corporation et al v. Assessor of Area 10 -- North Fraser Region and Property Assessment Appeal Board	January 18, 2010
SC534	Assessor of Area 01 -- Capital v. Lehigh Portland Cement Limited et al	February 11, 2010
SC533	John Lowan v. Assessor of Area 01 -- Capital et al	February 11, 2010
SC532	B.E.S. Investments Ltd. v. Assessor of Area 10 -- North Fraser Region and Property Assessment Appeal Board	January 05, 2010
SC531	Assessor of Area 10 -- North Fraser Region v. Abolhassan Sherkat and Property Assessment Appeal Board	June 25, 2009 (BCSC), October 15, 2009 (BCSC), February 8, 2010 (BCCA), January 21, 2011 (BCCA)
SC530	James T. Allard and Allard Contractors Ltd. v. Assessor of Area 10 -- North Fraser Region and Property Assessment Appeal Board	June 04, 2009 (BCSC), October 7, 2010 (BCCA)
SC529	Allard Contractors Ltd. v. Assessor of Area 04 -- Central Vancouver Island and Property Assessment Appeal Board	June 01, 2009
SC528	Marilyn Mandarino v. Assessor of Area 19 -- Kelowna and Property Assessment Appeal Board	April 28, 2009
SC527	Assessor of Area 09 -- Vancouver Sea to Sky Region and City of Vancouver v. Entre Nous Femmes Housing Society et al	March 16, 2009 (BCSC), July 29, 2009 (BCCA), May 25, 2010 (BCCA)
SC526	Jeri Lynn Patterson v. Assessor of Area 15 -- Fraser Valley et al	February 24, 2009
SC525	Assessor of Area 09 -- Vancouver Sea to Sky Region v. Four Seasons Hotel Limited et al	February 27, 2009

1 - 30

Compliance Details

javascript:commonShowModalDialog('{SiteUrl}'+ '/_layouts/15/itemexpiration.aspx' +'?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}', 'center:1;dialogHeight:500px;dialogWidth:500px;resizable:yes;status:no;location:no;menubar:no;help:no', function GotoPageAfterClose(pageid){if(pageid == 'hold') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+ '/_layouts/15/hold.aspx' +'?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;} if(pageid == 'audit') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+ '/_layouts/15/Reporting.aspx' +'?Category=Auditing&backtype=item&ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;} if(pageid == 'config') {STSNavigate(unescape(decodeURI('{SiteUrl}'))+ '/_layouts/15/expirationconfig.aspx' +'?ID={ItemId}&List={ListId}'); return false;}}, null);

0x0

0x1

ContentType

0x01

898

Document Set Version History

/_layouts/15/images/versions.gif?rev=23

javascript:SP.UI.ModalDialog.ShowPopupDialog('{SiteUrl}'+ '/_layouts/15/DocSetVersions.aspx' + '?List={ListId}&ID={ItemId}')

0x0

ContentType

0x0120D520

330

Send To other location

/_layouts/15/images/sendOtherLoc.gif?rev=23

javascript:GoToPage('{SiteUrl}' + '/_layouts/15/docsetsend.aspx' + '?List={ListId}&ID={ItemId}')

0x0

ContentType

0x0120D520

350

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

ODS

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

XLS

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

XLSB

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

XLSM

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

XLSX

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

ODS

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

XLSB

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

XLSM

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

XLSX

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

ProgId

OneNote.Notebook

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

ONE

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

ONETOC2

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

ProgId

OneNote.Notebook

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

ONE

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

ONETOC2

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

ODP

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

POT

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

POTM

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

POTX

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

PPS

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

PPSM

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

PPSX

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

PPT

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

PPTM

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

PPTX

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

ODP

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

PPSX

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

PPTX

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

DOC

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

DOCM

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

DOCX

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

DOT

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

DOTM

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

DOTX

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

ODT

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

DOCM

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

DOCX

255

Edit in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=edit&source={Source}

0x0

0x24

FileType

ODT

255

View in Browser

{SiteUrl}/_layouts/15/WopiFrame.aspx?sourcedoc={ItemUrl}&action=view&source={Source}

0x0

0x1

FileType

PDF

255